‘Mass Deportation Now’ plans fall apart under scrutiny, for Kansas and U.S. That’s not the point. (2024)

He wouldn’t say the name.

Surrounded by delegates waving “Mass Deportation Now” signs during the Republican National Convention, NBC reporter Jacob Soboroff – winner of several awards for his reporting, as well as his book on immigration policy – refused to repeat the name of the Eisenhower Administration program upon which former President Trump models his “largest deportation program in American history.”

It’s an offensive name, and racist, Soboroff told his colleagues in the studio.

Ike’s effort flopped. It repatriated only a scant faction of targeted immigrants.

Scores died in hell-hole ships returning them to Mexico. Corrupt growers thwarted attempts to detain workers. Its leader, who had been convicted years earlier of killing a Latino man, folded the program after a year.

Trump’s proposal is destined to the same fate, but that doesn’t matter to him or his followers.

The mass deportation pledge of 2024 is this year’s wall: Trump’s shorthand to incite his followers. The wall became the signature issue in his 2016 campaign. In his acceptance speech, Trump falsely claimed that most of it is finished.

The U.S.-Mexico border is 2,000 miles long. During his administration, the United States constructed just 50 miles of new border wall.

And Mexico didn’t pay.

But a real wall was not the goal, just as a legislative solution to border security was never the point. Trump told us so. He demanded his congressional allies oppose a bipartisan border bill so he could campaign on the issue. They did, and they don’t have a solution.

Now his supporters are waving Mass Deportation Now signs but know nothing about the proposal. It is devoid of detail, cost estimates and without regard for the consequences.

How would Kansas find the personnel and money for Trump’s plan? The state’s comparatively small population of undocumented migrants outnumbers – by nearly eight to one – its law enforcement force. Kansas would have to detail every single law enforcement officer – state, county, and local – solely to the door-to-door sweeps, traffic stops and detention activities the program would require.

It could easily cost as much as $770 million in Kansas alone.

Who would be detained? The French native who overstayed her visa by two years to live with her law firm partner boyfriend in Overland Park, or the undocumented Honduran working construction in Pratt, married, with children, and in the country for 15 years?

Nearly two-thirds of the undocumented migrants in Kansas have been here longer than 10 years; only an extremely small proportion have arrived in the last five years. The same share is married, more than 10% of them to U.S. citizens. More than half own their homes.

Which families will be torn apart? Who makes those decisions?

There aren’t enough lawyers and courts in Kansas to handle the inevitable avalanche of legal challenges.

Which buildings would go unbuilt, which factories would close, which farms and restaurants would limp along understaffed?

For every two unfilled jobs in Kansas, there is only one available worker, a ratio that would balloon to crippling levels. National studies suggest a drastic drop in growth if immigrants are removed from the work force; the Kansas economy is not immune.

What about the downstream costs?

The state and local budgets would suffer an immediate shock of lost revenues. Contrary to what Trump said at his convention, undocumented migrants cannot receive Social Security or Medicare, but the taxes they pay on their wages help finance these programs. They pay state and local taxes, too – taxes that help pay for the salaries of the public officials who would remove them.

Wouldn’t the crime rate fall?

The crime rate is already falling. It has dropped sharply in the last few years. Native U.S. citizens are far more likely to commit crimes than immigrants, far more. So, no.

The answers to these questions, the details, and fallout don’t matter to Trump and his followers, including most Kansas Republican office holders and candidates. They are irrelevant to the real point.

The attack on the other, the retrograde false dream of a country of white, Anglo-Saxon Christians, is being unleashed solely to get votes.

“Mass Deportation Now?” It’s a base appeal to the worst in politics.

If Ike’s program is the proposal’s model, its demagogic forebearers are Sen. Joseph McCarthy’s Red Scare; Alabama Gov. George Wallace’s “Segregation today, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever;” President Reagan’s “welfare queens” and President George H.W. Bush’s Willie Horton; and even Trump’s own Muslim ban. It sits with them in the abyss of political rhetoric.

Soboroff was right.

The name of the Trump model is offensive, degrading, and, thankfully, disappeared from contemporary discourse. But it’s important to know it – and say it, once – to understand the depths of the division Trump is sowing: Operation W–back.

We banished that racist term from our lexicon, as we should have. Its 2024 descendant deserves the same fate.

Raised in McPherson, Greg Frazier served in high-level positions at the USDA and Office of the United States Trade Representative, as well as on the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence. He has extensive experience dealing with the Chinese government.

‘Mass Deportation Now’ plans fall apart under scrutiny, for Kansas and U.S. That’s not the point. (2024)

References

Top Articles
Chattahoochee Okta
Late Skate - Cass County Calendar
Navin Dimond Net Worth
9Anime Keeps Buffering
Syracuse Pets Craigslist
Gasbuddy Costco Hawthorne
How Much Is Vivica Fox Worth
Lynaritaa Boobs
Delta Air Lines - Login
United Center: Home of the Chicago Bulls & Chicago Blackhawks - The Stadiums Guide
Swgoh Darth Vader Mods
Randolph Leader Obits
Wmlink/Sspr
Krystal Murphy Below Deck Net Worth
Air Force Chief Results
Hsclink.health.unm.edu
2024 Coachella Predictions
Gargoyle Name Generator
MyChart | University Hospitals
Enloe Bell Schedule
Joy Ride 2023 Showtimes Near Amc Ward Parkway
Insidekp.kp.org Myhr Portal
Truist Business Checking: 2024 Review
Dawat Restaurant Novi
The Ultimate Guide To Beautiful Spokane, Washington
Scenes from Paradise: Where to Visit Filming Locations Around the World - Paradise
Decree Of Spite Poe
Sejinming Telegram
Melanin - Altmeyers Enzyklopädie - Fachbereich Dermatologie
Erj Phone Number
Minor-Morris Recent Obituaries
Kidcheck Login
Po Box 182223 Chattanooga Tn 37422 7223
Lids Locker Room Vacaville Photos
Unveiling AnonIB: The Controversial Online Haven for Explicit Images - The Technology For The Next Generation.
Kostenlose Karneval Google Slides Themen & PowerPoint Vorlage
How To Get Coins In Path Of Titans
Anmed My Chart Login
Jan Markell Net Worth
France 2 Journal Télévisé 20H
Phase 3 Cataclysm Classic New Changes, Preparation and Investments Guide
Things To Do in Sanford, Florida - Historic Downtown Sanford
Honeywell V8043E1012 Wiring Diagram
Vhl Spanish 2 Answer Key
Every Act That's Auditioned for AGT Season 18 So Far
Souvenir Shopping and Local Markets in Belgium
Desi Cinemas.com
Tattoo Shops Buckhannon Wv
palm springs free stuff - craigslist
Dtm Urban Dictionary
Niw 一亩三分地
Sdn Michigan State Osteopathic 2023
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tyson Zemlak

Last Updated:

Views: 5565

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (43 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tyson Zemlak

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Apt. 662 96191 Quigley Dam, Kubview, MA 42013

Phone: +441678032891

Job: Community-Services Orchestrator

Hobby: Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Metalworking, Fashion, Vehicle restoration, Shopping, Photography

Introduction: My name is Tyson Zemlak, I am a excited, light, sparkling, super, open, fair, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.